10 Homemade ‘90s Snacks for a Sweet Taste of Nostalgia
Yes, you can make your favorite throwback treats!
If you grew up in the ‘90s, you probably remember that the snack selection was simply unmatched. Whether you unpeeled a Fruit Roll-Up from your school lunchbox, devoured a plate of Bagel Bites as an after-school snack, or tore open a Chipwich from the Good Humor truck, ‘90s kids know that snack time was a whole other level of fun. If you want to take a stroll down memory lane or share all your favorite throwback treats with your kids, these homemade takes on ‘90s snacks will give you the sweetest taste of nostalgia.
Remember Dunkaroos? Well, our list has an equally delicious variation with animal-shaped shortbread cookies and confetti frosting that you can make from scratch. What about Choco Tacos? Yep, there’s a recipe for that, too (and it might even be better than the original). Our roundup even includes a copycat version of a Frosted Strawberry Pop Tart!
Ahead, you’ll find so many other childhood staples from sweet treats like pudding cups and ice cream bars to savory snacks like pizza rolls and pigs in a blanket. Whether you’re craving chocolate desserts or something cheesy, there’s a recipe below that’s calling your name! So, scroll through these homemade ‘90s snacks, and get ready to relive your glory days.
Strawberry Shortcake Bars
This copycat will give you the same thrill as hearing the Good Humor truck drive down your childhood block! You just need five ingredients to pull off this frozen treat.
Get the Homemade Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Bars recipe.
Nutella Krispie Treats
While the original vanilla flavor always hit the spot, you can recreate this ’90s classic by adding Nutella to the marshmallow mixture. Top each bar with toasted pecans, mini marshmallows, and a chocolate drizzle.
Get Ree’s Nutella Krispie Treats recipe.
Homemade Dunkaroos
Ah yes, a peak ‘90s snack! Remember the joy of dunking animal-shaped cookies into fluffy frosting? Relive it through these homemade Dunkaroos. The cookies and sugary-sweet, sprinkle-speckled frosting are such a winning combination.
Get the Homemade Dunkaroos recipe.
Pizza Bagels
For a heartier, more sophisticated spin on Bagel Bites, layer sliced asiago bagels with all the toppings you see fit. This ‘90s-inspired snack comes together in 15 minutes, whether you opt for classic pepperoni or prosciutto with goat cheese and arugula.
Get the Pizza Bagels recipe.
Pigs in a Blanket
It’s the most popular appetizer of the last half-century, ‘90s included: pigs in a blanket! Smoky sausages wrapped in flaky pastry dough might just be your new favorite way to make this nostalgic bite. For an adult-approved finish, sprinkle on everything bagel seasoning.
Get the Pigs in a Blanket recipe.
Homemade Choco Tacos
Choco Tacos might be discontinued, but you can still bask in the nutty, chocolaty goodness! Simply scoop ice cream into a shell-shaped waffle cone, pop it into the freezer, dip it in melted chocolate, and garnish it with a dusting of chopped peanuts.
Get the Homemade Choco Tacos recipe.
Homemade Pop Tarts
Whether you had them for breakfast, snack, or dessert, Pop Tarts were always a good idea as a kid. Recreating the ‘90s snack couldn’t be easier, thanks to shortcuts like refrigerated pie crust and store-bought jam.
Get the Homemade Pop Tarts recipe.
Mozzarella Sticks
Featuring a crispy breaded coating and molten cheesy center, mozzarella sticks taste just as good even decades later! Slices of mozzarella are fried in oil until they turn gooey and golden. Dip them in tangy marinara sauce!
Get Ree’s Mozzarella Sticks recipe.
Pepperoni Pizza Rolls
Reminiscent of ‘90s pizza rolls, this pepperoni version features all the saucy, cheesy deliciousness. But instead of hiding inside the dough, it’s rolled up in gooey layers, so there’s a pizza party in every bite!
Get Ree’s Pepperoni Pizza Rolls recipe.
Chocolate Pudding
With this easy recipe, you can make ‘90s-style pudding cups in 20 minutes tops! This one has a silky-smooth consistency and a graham cracker base that’ll melt in your mouth. Eat it by the spoonful, or pile on whipped cream and chocolate shavings.
Get the Chocolate Pudding recipe.
15 Things to Always Have in Your Fridge for School
Sheet Pan Broccoli Cheddar Quesadillas
3-Ingredient Buffalo Chicken Dip
10 Pretzel Recipes That Go Way Beyond Snack Time
