Skip to Content

Sugar Cookie Eyeballs

They're deliciously creepy!

By Ree DrummondPublished: Apr 14, 2020

3.7

sugar cookie eyeballs halloween dessert

Ryan Dausch

Yields:

24

Prep Time:

10 mins

Cook Time:

12 mins

Total Time:

22 mins

These fun, easy Halloween cookies will delight kids of all ages. You'll want to use a mini muffin pan to get the right look.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Ingredients

16 oz. tube sugar cookie dough
White candy melts, melted
Green M&Ms
Black icing

Directions

1. Step 1Coat a 24-cup mini-muffin pan with cooking spray.
2. Step 2Cut a 16.5-ounce tube sugar cookie dough into 6 slices, then quarter each slice. Press a piece of dough into each muffin cup.
3. Step 3Bake at 350° until set, 12 minutes; let cool. Fill with melted white candy melts and top each with a green M&M. Use black icing to make the pupils.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Halloween 2025

fall wreaths

Welcome Fall with a Wreath on Your Front Door

Anthropologie halloween collection 2026

Shop Anthropologie’s Chic Halloween Collection

fall decorating checklist

When to Decorate for Fall, Plus a Handy Checklist!

lenox halloween spice village 2026

Lenox Just Released a Halloween Spice Village

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Pottery Barn Halloween Collection 2026

Decorate Early with Pottery Barn's Halloween Line

halfway to halloween decorations

Now Is the Time for Deals on Halloween Décor

practical magic 2 teaser trailer

Get a First Look at ‘Practical Magic 2’

the pioneer woman's mulled apple cider recipe

Ree’s Mulled Apple Cider Recipe Is a Seasonal Must

alex drummond instagram sofia cow

See Sofia's Adorable Halloween Costume This Year

how long does halloween candy last

How Long Does Halloween Candy Last?

what time does trick or treating start

Here's When to Trick-or-Treat This Halloween

halloween dinner recipes

50 Halloween Dinner Ideas to Sink Your Fangs Into

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below